The Best Tenant Screening Services

Home » Blog » Buying Guides » Services » The Best Tenant Screening Services

Which is the Best Tenant Screening Service?

Getting accurate information about potential tenants is a mission-critical task for your property management business. We reviewed 20 tenant screening services and picked five that we like and have used personally in the past.

  1. TransUnion Smart Move
  2. Experian Connect
  3. TenantAlert
  4. MyRental by CoreLogic
  5. RentPrep

These are the criteria we used to evaluate the tenant screening services.

  • Cost
  • Renter pay option – choice of who pays for the report
  • How long does it take to receive a report?
  • Credit report
  • Background check
  • Eviction report
  • Criminal report
  • Rental scoring
  • Income insight report
  • Reference check
  • Employment check
  • Residence check
CriteriaTransUnionSmart MoveExperian ConnectTenantAlertMyRental by CoreLogicRentPrep
Cost $40$14.95$39.95$34.99$48
Renter Pay OptionYesYesYesYesYes
How Long Does it TakeInstantInstantInstantInstantOne Hour
Credit ReportYesYesYesYesYes
Criminal Background CheckYesNoYesYesYes
Rental ScoreYesNoNoYesYes
Income Insights ReportYesNoNoNoYes
Reference CheckNoNoNoNo
Employer VerificationNoNoNoNoYes
Residence VerificationNoNoNoNo

TransUnion Smart Move

SmartMove is a tenant screening service run by TransUnion. Enrollment for landlords is free and anyone can start screening tenants immediately.

After enrolling and entering your property, you can start processing applications by clicking on the add application button.

Why we like TransUnion Smart move?

For beginner landlords and newer property managers, SmartMove offers two reports that are invaluable: rental score and income insight reports.

Because most landlords are not credit experts, they need an interpretation of the data in the credit report. SmartMove does that and makes a recommendation if the tenant should be accepted, rejected, or accepted with a higher deposit.

The Income Insight Report performs a preliminary income check on your tenant. You can use this to determine if additional verification is required.

And, finally, you can get the tenant to pay for this screening report with one click.

Experian Connect

Experian Connect offers the lowest price of all screening services but landlords only get a credit report.

There is also an option for the tenant to pay for this report.

Tenant Alert

What we like about Tenant Alert?

Tenant Alert can screen potential tenants but also it offers a Lease Guarantee at additional $299 (this price may change check with the company)

MyRental by CoreLogic

CoreLogic is the company that provides valuation reports to multiple MLS and it also provides underwriting and risk management for many lenders and investors.

What we like about MyRental?

We like the SafeRent Score which shows the level of risk you are taking with a potential applicant.

RentPrep

RentPrep is a team of FCRA Certified Screeners, who offer the TranUnion Report but they will also search liens and judgements

What we like about RentPrep?

RentPrep offers full tenant screening that’s not available in most credit reports. Some of this data like liens and judgments requires manual extraction.

Related Articles:

How to Automate Tenant Pre-Screening

How to Screen Tenants the Right Way

First Time Landlord Guide

About the author

Chris Christo owns a property maintenance company and writes for Rentce on all rental maintenance topics.
He is also a rehabber and a landlord.
When he doesn’t work on properties or writes about properties, he can be found fishing.

1 thought on “The Best Tenant Screening Services”

Leave a Comment

Rentce is reader-supported. Some of the links in this post are affiliate links. This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, we may earn a commission.