Top 10 Property Management Companies in Orlando

As former owners of a property management company, we know exactly what matters in managing rental properties. We chose the criteria that are crucial for finding an experienced property manager, who will make your real estate investment profitable, and evaluated 30 companies.

From this list we picked the top 10.

This is the criteria we used to evaluate all companies. We read through all the reviews, checked the companies’ online listings, BBB complaints, state licensing standing, participation in the local associations, and general reputation.

• Responsiveness – how easy it is to see a listed property
• Efforts to reduce vacancies – does the company market the rental before the current tenant moves out
• Days on market – how long listing stays on the market
• Presentation of listings – photos and videos of the rentals
• Reputation – heavily weighted on landlord reviews
• Length in business – how long has the company been in business
• Industry participation and reputation – participation in local property management associations and designations.
• Cost

Central Florida Property Management

Responsiveness	5
Efforts to reduce vacancies	5
Days on market	5
Presentation of listings	5
Reputation	5
Length in business	4
Industry participation and reputation	4
Cost	3.5
Total score	4.5

Atrium Management Company

Responsiveness	3
Efforts to reduce vacancies	5
Days on market	5
Presentation of listings	4.5
Reputation	4.5
Length in business	5
Industry participation and reputation	5
Cost	3
Total score	4.38

The Listing Real Estate Management

Responsiveness	5
Efforts to reduce vacancies	5
Days on market	4.5
Presentation of listings	5
Reputation	4.5
Length in business	2
Industry participation and reputation	4
Cost	4
Total score	4.25

HomeRiver Group

Responsiveness	4
Efforts to reduce vacancies	5
Days on market	4
Presentation of listings	3.5
Reputation	4.4
Length in business	5
Industry participation and reputation	4
Cost	3.5
Total score	4.17

Bahia Property Management

Responsiveness	3
Efforts to reduce vacancies	3
Days on market	5
Presentation of listings	4
Reputation	5
Length in business	5
Industry participation and reputation	4
Cost	3
Total score	4

Verandah Properties, LLC

Responsiveness	3
Efforts to reduce vacancies	5
Days on market	2
Presentation of listings	4
Reputation	3.5
Length in business	5
Industry participation and reputation	5
Cost	3
Total score	3.81

All County CFL Property Management

Responsiveness	4
Efforts to reduce vacancies	3
Days on market	2.6
Presentation of listings	3.8
Reputation	3.5
Length in business	4
Industry participation and reputation	4
Cost	4
Total score	3.61

Specialized Property Management

Responsiveness	4
Efforts to reduce vacancies	5
Days on market	3.4
Presentation of listings	3
Reputation	4.5
Length in business	2
Industry participation and reputation	4
Cost	3
Total score	3.61

Allegiant Management Group

Responsiveness	4
Efforts to reduce vacancies	3
Days on market	2.5
Presentation of listings	3
Reputation	4.5
Length in business	3
Industry participation and reputation	5
Cost	3
Total score	3.5

Real Property Management South Orlando

Responsiveness	4
Efforts to reduce vacancies	3
Days on market	2
Presentation of listings	3
Reputation	3.5
Length in business	4
Industry participation and reputation	4
Cost	3
Total score	3.31